Like many new corporate logos, the new Microsoft Windows 8 logo has created a healthy debate. You will find those that love the new simplistic design. Other "flag" fanboys infer that the operating system itself will be dummied down like the logo. While others claim that this is an attempt to become more Apple-like.
I also read that it is very appropriate to have four blue screens of death represent Microsoft but I feel that the literal interpretation of crafting a window icon along with an Arial-ish wordmark will serve Microsoft well. I believe Time Magazine’s Harry McCracken had the best take...
“I don’t want to be wowed by my operating system–I want it to get out of my face, and not break, and generally be a platform for useful applications that make my life better rather than a glorious experience unto itself.”
Microsoft’s Sam Moreau explains the reasoning behind the minimalist look:
With Windows 8, we approached the logo redesign with a few key goals on mind.
1. We wanted the new logo to be both modern and classic by echoing the International Typographic Style (or Swiss design) that has been a great influence on our Metro style design philosophy. Using bold flat colors and clean lines and shapes, the new logo has the characteristics of way-finding design systems seen in airports and subways.
2. It was important that the new logo carries our Metro principle of being “Authentically Digital”. By that, we mean it does not try to emulate faux-industrial design characteristics such as materiality (glass, wood, plastic, etc.). It has motion – aligning with the fast and fluid style you’ll find throughout Windows 8.
3. Our final goal was for the new logo to be humble, yet confident. Welcoming you in with a slight tilt in perspective and when you change your color, the logo changes to reflect you. It is a “Personal” Computer after all.
Ultimately it will be the product experience that will drive the feelings about the brand, not the logo alone. If the product "makes my life better" then the logo will be a success.